A Brief History
of
FIRST PRESBYTERIAN CHURCH
Wheaton, Illinois
by
John Robert Houliston

HISTORIAN'S NOTE:
John Robert Houliston (pronounced Holliston) was a Scotsman
by heritage and a Presbyterian through and through. He was a distinguished
Clerk of the Session, serving so many years beyond his terms as
a ruling Elder that the Reverend Dr. Stewart bestowed upon him
the honorary title, "Dean of the Session." Thereafter,
he was affectionately called Dean Houliston by fellow-members.
Though he lived to be 104, no one thought to ask him the dates
of his writing of the local church history! Thus, in reading any
copy of the manuscript history it should be kept in mind that
some of it appears to be the original body of work which took
the story only into the 1930's. A later version--this being an
example--updates the history through the laying of the cornerstone
for the new sanctuary on Jefferson Street in 1954.
For those interested, the Church Historian's files offer
biographical material and photographs pertaining to Mr.
Houliston's personal life and his valuable contribution to First
Presbyterian Church.
Maurine M. Krohne
1986
SOURCES:
Minutes of the First Church of Christ in Wheaton 1866-1879
Minutes of the First Congregational Church 1879-1909
Minutes of the First Presbyterian Church 1909-1952
A History of DuPage County, Richmond & Vallette 1857
A History of DuPage County, C. W. Richmond 1876
History of DuPage County, Rufus Blanchard 1882
Report of Council of Congregational Churches Held in Wheaton in
February 1879
A
BRIEF HISTORY OF THE FIRST PRESBYTERIAN CHURCH, WHEATON, ILLINOIS
by JOHN R. HOULISTON
BEGINNINGS.
An historian of the last century wrote "The truly reformatory
movements of the day find warm supporters here (Wheaton) so much
so that it has been denominated a "reformatory town."
Kossuth said "Nothing in the past is dead to him who would know
how the present came to be." To understand the history of the
First Presbyterian Church of Wheaton it is necessary to go back to
its origin; to know something of the character and the aims of its
"founding fathers" with their beliefs and prejudices; to consider
some of the issues of the day and where they stood on these
issues, and to take into account the difficulties under which they
labored with most primitive means of transportation and
communication. How their ideas and beliefs were woven into that
first organization and how the church has faired under three flags
makes an interesting story.
Prior to the Blackhawk war no settler in northern Illinois was
safe from pillage or murder by the Indians but with the banishment
of the tribes beyond the Mississippi river the area became open to
settlement. Milton Township saw the first settlers arrive in 1831
in the persons of Harry F. Wilson and Lyman Butterfield; Ralph and
Morgan Babcock and Thomas Brown settled in this town soon after.
They were followed by Joseph Chadwick and his sons.
The Chadwicks made their home in what was later called the
Hadley neighborhood, in the vicinity of the present Chicago Golf
Club. They came from Northern New York where bitter opposition
against the Masonic orders had developed and they had acquired a
great dislike to any and all oath-bound secret societies. New
England and New York were becoming very antislavery and Chadwick
brought with him a keen hatred of slavery. He was not without his
prejudices against liquor, tobacco, cards, dancing and the
theater. He believed that man was made for the Sabbath and he
observed it. His material possessions were just the necessary
articles that could be carried in a Conestoga wagon.
When Chadwick reached Milton Township there were no roads or
bridges, just Indian trails. In fact from Ottawa north to the
Wisconsin line there were no settlements excepting Chicago on Lake
Michigan and Galena on the Mississippi excepting a few families et
Bureau Creek, Indian Creek, Dixon, Kellog's Grove and Apple River,
about thirty in all. All supplies had to be hauled from Chicago by
wagon and then only in dry weather when the roads were passable.
The close of the Blackhawk war in 1833 banished the Indians to
beyond the Mississippi river and opened this part of the state to
settlers. At once there was a great influx from New England and
northern New York. They came by wagon bringing only the bearest
necessities. But they brought strong bodies and strong minds with
courage to face lonliness and privations while they carved homes
for themselves and their children out of this vast wilderness.
To the vicinity of what is now Wheaton came the Garys, the
Wheatons and the Hadleys and a host of other strong rugged men and
women. Most of these pioneers held deep religious convictions and
readily responded to the missionary preachers sent out by the
Baptists, Methodists and the American Board of Home Missions to
which the Congregationalists and the Presbyterians subscribed.
There was Methodist preaching at Stacy's Corners, now known as
Five Points in Glen Ellyn, and at Gary's Mill near Winfield. The
Baptists organized a church at Warrenville and the Presbyterians
had churches at Plainfield, Big Wood and Batavia.
Considering the loneliness of the pioneer life without
newspapers, telephones or radio and travel confined to the speed
of horses or oxen it is not surprising that the people eagerly
awaited the coming of a circuit rider minister or an itinerant
preacher and came some distance to worship and to make social
contacts.
Politics and religion were the main topics of discussion. These
were days of intense partisanship and the question of slavery or
antislavery held first place in popular interest. The issue
invaded the churches setting one congregation against another in
the same denomination. This was particularly true in the great
Methodist church. In New York State some of the churches withdrew
their affiliation with the Methodist church to start a new
denomination which they called Wesleyan Methodist. Word of this
movement must have reached Joseph Chadwick. Being an ardent
abolitionist he longed for a church that would measure up to his
standards not only on slavery but on many other questions as well.
After calling on his neighbors he invited them to meet at his
home one Sunday morning in February 1843. Fourteen families
accepted his invitation and proceeded to organize a Wesleyan
Methodist church, the first church established in the area which
was so soon to become Wheaton. The first minister called was the
Reverend Rufus Lumry, a fire eating abolitionist. His tenure was
not long and he was succeeded by Milton Smith and later by
Alexander McArthur, then L. B. Ferris. In fact ten ministers
served the church in its first twelve years.
Six years after this organization came into being a railroad
was built, a station was erected on the Wheaton property and the
place called Wheaton. A town grew rapidly around the station and
it soon became the business and social center of the area. By the
year 1860 Wheaton had grown to village of 600 people. In November
of 1856 a Baptist church was organized and in October of the next
year the Methodist church was established. Richmond and Vallette's
History of DuPage County lists the churches in Wheaton as follows;
Wesleyan Methodist about 75 members, Episcopal Methodist about 60
members, Baptist Church 17 members.
Prior to 1847 all of the churches of Presbyterian form of
government in Cook and DuPage counties were members of the Ottawa
Presbytery. To attend a meeting of Presbytery required a long and
difficult journey which required several days. There were three
such churches around here. The church at Batavia, the one at Big
Woods and the third, known as the Plainfield church was located
some miles south of Naperville on the DuPage river. Sometime in
the late thirties the Fox River Association of Congregational
Churches was formed and these Presbyterian churches were invited
to join. Batavia and Big Woods accepted the invitation and no
longer sent representatives to Ottawa. Plainfield moved into
Naperville and joined the Association. A few years later a part of
the membership of this church withdrew and reestablished its home
at the old site. In this church in October 1847 the Presbytery of
Chicago was born. The Synod of Peoria had detached the counties of
Lake, Cook, DuPage and Will to form the new Presbytery. In all
this territory only four Presbyterian churches existed, two at
Chicago, one at Joliet and the fourth was the country parish known
as Plainfield.
New Englanders firmly believed in higher education as was
witnessed by the numerous fine colleges and universities already
established there. The settlers from New England wanted their
children given like opportunities and especially schools that
would fit them for the ministry and other learned professions.
Each denomination sought to found at least one college and one
Divinity school to prepare their young men for the Gospel
ministry. The Wesleyans were not to be outdone in this matter of
education. They wanted a school where the laws of their church,
which they called "testimonies" would be taught and strictly
enforced. These testimonies called for the abolition of slavery;
no member of the church in good standing could belong to any
oath-bound secret society; the church forbad the use of liquor,
tobacco, cards, dancing, gambling, attending the theater, and
called for a strict observance of the Sabbath. With the
cooperation of the other Wesleyan churches in northern Illinois,
Wheaton was chosen as the best location for such a school. A site
for the campus was secured, a building erected and the first
classes of the Illinois Institute began in the Autumn of 1853. It
is evident the school building also was the home of the church.
When in 1856 the first president was installed, the Reverend
Lucius C. Matlack, he was also made the minister of the church.
Financial troubles beset the college from the start and in 1859
the Wesleyans called upon their Congregational friends for help.
The Congregational Association refused to undertake the
responsibility because they already had two or three colleges and
a Theological Seminary to support but there were some individuals
who said they would undertake helping to support the school on
condition that Dr. Jonathan Blanchard, who had been president of
Knox College and who was now preaching in Galesburg, was made
president. The Wesleyans accepted the conditions and offered Dr.
Blanchard the presidency. As he was fundamentally in agreement
with all of the Wesleyan "testimonies" he accepted the call and
took up the work January first 1860. As the former president had
left and the church had no minister, Dr. Blanchard supplied the
pulpit for a time at least.
Within a month after coming to Wheaton Dr. Blanchard sought to
have the church join the Fox Valley Association of Congregational
Churches. While agreeing to this the church made a stipulation
that the testimonies relating to slavery, Masonry, etc. should
remain in the manual and be strictly observed. Writing some twenty
years later Dr. Blanchard says, "which condition has been sacredly
observed."
At this time the name of the church was changed from the
Wesleyan church to the First Church of Christ in Wheaton. Under
Dr. Blanchard's ministry the church had a satisfactory growth but
the Wesleyans were not happy under the new arrangements and
twenty-eight of them withdrew two years later to form a Wesleyan
church which was still in existence in 1882.
There is no mention in the records of a house of worship and it
is quite probable that as the church and the college were so
closely associated worship was conducted in one of the college
buildings. At any rate, when the college completed a new building
in 1872, which included a chapel, a committee was appointed by the
church to arrange with the college for the joint use of the
building. The members of the college faculty, with their families,
and the student body, made up a goodly part of the church and were
well represented among its officers.
The completion of the college chapel gave the church the most
commodious quarters it had ever enjoyed. Money for church expenses
must be raised and the prevalent custom of renting pews was
adopted. The pews were "sold" at the start of the year at a price
that depended upon location and of course the most desirable pews
brought the highest price. There were a few unrented pews that
could be used by non pew holders and visitors or if a family was
late they might find the usher had seated some one else there.
Pledges were also asked for additional funds for current expenses
and benevolences. In order to expedite the collection of rents and
pledges the church appointed a collector who was to receive a
percentage of what he collected as pay for his services. The
contributer could save this for the church if he would pay the
treasurer direct before the collector got to him. The collector
plan did not prove very satisfactory and was soon abandoned but
the rental of pews continued for many years.
Late in the year 1877 a storm suddenly developed. An endowment
fund of $12,000 had been raised in the East: by a Mr. Webster to
endow a chair on the faculty of Wheaton College. It was understood
that Mr. Webster would receive the appointment as soon as the fund
was in hand. Mr. Webster turned over the cash to Dr. Blanchard, in
trust as he supposed for the endowment. Shortly afterward, when
the college was pressed for money to meet current bills, Dr.
Blanchard secured Professor Webster's consent to the use of $1200
as a temporary loan. Not long after this the college needed three
thousand dollars. Again President Blanchard asked Professor
Webster to lend the money from the endowment. To this Professor
Webster objected on the grounds that the fund would soon be
dissipated and the money given by his friends for his support
would have bean used for other purposes. Nevertheless the money
was withdrawn and as a result of his protests Webster was
dismissed and his work given to a younger man. What remained of
the endowment was used to support the new professor.
Many friends of Professor Webster thought the treatment he had
received both dishonest and dishonorable on the part of President
Blanchard. One of these, Mr. J. M. Chapman, expressed his feelings
on a suburban train one morning and went so far as to call the
President a thief. The remark was overheard by H. L. Kellogg,, a
relative of the President and an officer in the church. He called
a meeting of the congregation at which he preferred charges
against Mr. Chapman. The charges were sustained at this meeting
and Chapman was "denied the fellowship of the Church until he
should repent and seek forgivenness." Chapman made his confession
of repentance but the Church refused to restore him to fellowship.
Professor Webster now brought charges against President
Blanchard for "slander and personal wrong in depriving him of his
place on the faculty and defrauding him of his equitable pecunary
right." To this Webster's friends gave their active support. The
College element, controlling a majority of the votes of the
Church, exhonorated Dr. Blanchard.
Professor Webster then asked that a congregational meeting be
called for the purpose of calling a Council of Congregational
Churches to review the whole matter. The meeting was set for
January third 1878. The meeting was duly constituted following the
usual prayer meeting. Before considering the object of the meeting
a communication was read which ended with a resolution to dissolve
the church. This motion was given the right of way. The motion
asked that the present church be dissolved and in its place two
churches be established, allowing each member to choose which one
he wished to join. The vote resulted in 57 yeas and 23 nays. The
church was thereupon declared dissolved. There being no longer a
church they could not call a Council or transact any other
business. The meeting adjourned.
The minority claimed the action was illegal as the call for the
meeting clearly stated the purpose was to consider calling a
Council of the churches and made no mention of any other business.
Certainly there was no mention of dissolving the church given as
one of the objects of the meeting and that such a motion should
have been ruled out of order. However it was a fact accomplished
and some eighty members proceeded to organize a new church and
adopted the name of the College Church of Christ. The others would
not recognize the vote of dissolution and continued as the First
Church of Christ. They retained their membership in the
Congregational Association and the minister, Reverend L. Taylor,
but they were barred from meeting in a college building by Dr.
Blanchard who had given the use of the chapel to the new church.
The church found they were able to rent the building of the
Universalists on Wesley street just east of Main. This building
was later sold to Dr. Oelke who moved it to its present location
and converted it into a Medical building. The church paid a rental
of $3.50 per Sabbath. This included heat, light and janitor
service. Here the church worshiped throughout the year 1878.
Immediately after the separation the church called a Council of
Congregational Churches which met in the Baptist church Wheaton
during February. In their published report the Council found "That
the First Church of Christ in Wheaton was not dissolved, and could
not either morally or in accordance with Congregational usage be
dissolved by the passage of the resolution mentioned. That the
First Church of Christ in Wheaton continues and all members who
remain obedient to the Covenant of the Church retain the full
rights of membership." "By decision of the Council lately held in
this place, the First Church of Christ was not dissolved by the
vote on the evening of January 3rd. (1878) and that all those who
are absenting themselves from the worship and ordinances of the
church are yet members thereof and are under covenant of
obligations and responsibility there to". It also found against
Dr. Blanchard.
Although called upon to return to their church the College
group ignored the Council and Dr. Blanchard contended that as he
had been exhonorated by his own church the Council had no
jurisdiction and no authority in the matter. Dr. Blanchard found,
however, that he no longer had his former power and influence over
Congregational churches nor was the College Church able to secure
membership in the Congregational Association for over ten years
when the First Church finally withdrew their objections.
Dr. Blanchard's account of the affair is as follows;
"Difficulties having arisen in 1877 of a complex nature,
stimulated by an officer of a Masonic lodge outside, at a written
request of about eighty members, the church voted to dissolve and
become two churches, allowing the members to go with either body
as they chose. Some 30 active members withdrew and afterward
changed the name of the First Church of Christ in Wheaton to the
First Congregational Church of Wheaton and also struck from the
manual their testimonies against secret lodges."
This whole sad affair had no place in the House of God. If
Professor Webster had been wronged the matter should have been
taken to the civil courts. It is certain no just settlement could
be made with tempers aroused to the melting point. Doubtless Mr.
Chapman's remarks were injudicious but when he recalled them the
opposition refused to reinstate him in the church. The move to
dissolve the church was to save Dr. Blanchard from facing a
Council of disinterested parties who had no bias. The matter was
an affair of the College to which the church nor the Council had
any authority but might only advise.
THE CHURCH BUILDING.
The most pressing need of the church was a house of worship.
The arrangements with the Universalists was at best only
temporary. In June a committee was selected to secure a suitable
site for a church building. This committee selected the Grom lot
at the southeast corner of Hale and Seminary Sts. five rods on
Hale street and eight rods on Seminary street which could be
purchased for eight hundred dollars. A building committee was
appointed to secure plans and funds for the erection of a
building. To this committee the names of Mr. J. Q. Adams and Mr.
Patrick were added. This is the first mention of Mr. Adams in the
minutes. He was destined to play a very important part in the
future of the church.
The plans chosen called for a building fifty feet square. The
sanctuary would occupy the north three-quarters of the interior
with sliding doors separating it from the south quarter which was
to be used for Sunday School and prayer meetings. By raising the
doors the room could be used as an overflow when needed. There was
to be a belfry on the northwest corner and the entrance was
through this section. The corner stone was laid August 20th 1878
and the building completed and dedicated on Wednesday January 2nd.
1879. The dedicatory sermon was preached by Dr. Goodwin, pastor of
the First Congregational Church of Chicago.
The building cost $5230.00 exclusive of the lot, making the
total cost $6030.00. Most of the money had been raised among the
members and their many friends in Wheaton but they still needed
$1500.00 to complete their payments to the builders. This was
raised by placing a mortgage for that amount on the property at 9%
interest and had one year to run. During the year efforts were
made to raise the debt and with the aid of $300.00 borrowed from
the Congregational Church Building Society the debt was paid in
full when it came due.
Immediately upon completion of the new church the members
decided to change the name from the First Church of Christ in
Wheaton to the First Congregational Church of Wheaton. A statement
of the change was duly recorded by the County Recorder January 15,
1879. The manuel was revised a few months later to conform to the
polity of the Congregational Church. Up to this time the old
Wesleyan manuel had been in use. The new manuel omitted the
"testimonies" against slavery (a dead issue now), masonry, etc.
but to satisfy a minority, it stated that the church did not look
with favor upon such things but held that these were questions
which each member must decide for himself according to the
dictates of his conscience.
The critics of the church lost no time in telling the public
that the church no longer had any principles. Smarting under this
criticism and feeling that the testimonies should have been
strongly reiterated, the minister, the Reverend L. Taylor,
resigned.
A committee was appointed, which included Mr. John Quincy
Adams, to secure a new minister. They chose the Reverend Augustine
G. Hibbard, who began his ministry September first 1881, after the
pulpit had been vacant for a year.
Mr. John Quincy Adams was elected to the Board of Trustees in
1884 where he was made the chairman, a post he retained until his
death in 1899.
The church was fortunate in having among its members the
Reverend William E. Brewster and his family. Mr. Brewster had
served the church as its minister during the late sixties and now
at the age of retirement he had returned to Wheaton to make his
home with his son George H. Brewster. The retired minister might
have cast his lot with the College Church but for the fact that he
had some life insurance in a fraternal insurance company and that
church would not accept him unless he surrendered that insurance.
The "testimonies" covering secret societies barred him from their
fellowship. He exerted a wise, kindly and tolerant influence with
his fellow members until his death at a ripe old age in 1894. His
son George H. Brewster was the treasurer of the church for a great
many years and after the change to the Presbyterian church he
became one of its first elders. He remained on the Session until a
charge in the rules of succession was made in 1925 when the church
made him an Elder Emeritus, the only man who has been so honored.
The third generation of this grand old family was represented by
Mrs. Frank Goalding, his daughter. Although she was a cripple from
childhood, requiring the constant use of crutches, she seldom
missed a day from the Sunday School where she had charge of the
primary department for fifty years.
The new church building was quite an addition to the small town
of Wheaton. It faced on Hale street overlooking the Gary home. It
was built of frame on a stone foundation and had a belfry on the
northwest corner directly over the entrance. Small pinnacles
ornamented the southwest and northeast corners. The entrance steps
led up directly from the street corner. Against the east wall of
the sanctuary stood the rostrum and pulpit with a marble topped
communion table directly in front of it. A hugh stove in the
northeast corner of the room furnished the heat and on a cold
winter day one would not wish to be far away from it but pity
those who happened to be too close. Oil lamps furnished the light
and a small organ the music. The pews were cushioned and would
seat about one hundred and eighty persons. They were all numbered
and were rented to the members on a yearly basis. Thus each family
occupied their accustomed place on Sabbath morning. Visitors were
shown to unrented pews unless a family was known to be away or
were unusually late in arriving at the church, when he might be
shown to one of the better seats.
The residence of William Grote adjoined the church on the
south. He wanted the vacant space that was between his home and
the church. The trustees thought they needed the money more than
they did the land so a deal was made by which they deeded five and
one half feet by one hundred and seventeen feet to Mr. Grote for
sixty dollars. The deed was dated August 11, 1881. The church
finally bought the Grote property and these five and a half feet
came back to it at a cost of sixteen hundred and fifty dollars.
The membership of the church, after the secession, was reported
in 1878 as sixty-five and the following year as sixty-six.
Doubtless there were some nonresident or inactive members included
in this count. In 1880 it had dropped to sixty and by 1882 only
forty-six remained on the roll. The low of all time was reached in
1883 when a membership of thirty-eight was reported. It rose
slowly from that time until it had again reached sixty-five in
1890. A copy of the report for 1900 to the Congregational
Association shows a membership of eighty-seven but it admits
thirty-four of these were nonresident. During the next five years
the church grew to one hundred and forty-seven only to decline the
next year to one hundred and thirty-eight. It had taken
twenty-eight years to increase the membership by seventy-three
souls.
The slow growth of the church membership with its frequent and
costly setbacks cannot but reflect on the character of its
ministry during these years. There were fifteen ministers engaged
from 1881 to 1909 and there were numerous periods when the pulpit
was filled by temporary supplies. The average tenure of each
pastorate was less than two years while the longest was only five
years and that was divided into two periods with a year between
them.
One of these ministers, the Reverend Mr. Carr, resigned October
26,1904 and a committee consisting of Messers Jones, Ames and
Banning was appointed to nominate his successor. The committee
agreed on a Reverend Mr. Williams but learned at the last moment
that Mr. Williams had changed his plans. This was reported to the
church January 18, 1906. The committee again reported on March
first that a candidate had withdrawn because the salary offered
was too low and that another could not accept a call "at present".
The result of this report was that the question of a new minister
was thrown into the lap of the church members.
Three weeks later a business meeting was held to take an
informal vote on a minister. Four names were presented which
resulted in a vote of 14, 11, 5, and 4. The last name was dropped
which resulted in a vote of 17, 12, and 8. None of the candidates
was chosen but on April 19th. the committee presented the name of
a Reverend Mr. James of St. Louis who received the unanimous vote
of the twenty present.
Seeds of discord had been planted in these meetings and they
germinated rapidly. By the time Mr. James arrived to assume his
duties on May first more than fifteen letters of dismissal had
been granted and among these who were leaving were some of the
main supporters of the church, such as the Fishers, Morgans,
Clevelands, Pringles and Grinnells.
The loss of so many members whose financial support was so
sorely needed gave the officers who were charged with the
wellbeing of the church much concern. For many years there had
been two Congregational churches in Wheaton. They were unalike in
many respects but who knew it until they had united with one or
the other! They both carried the Congregational banner but one
adheared to the "testimonies" of the Wesleyans while the other the
polity of the Congregational church. The College church still
worshipped in the College chapel and had the College support.
Their membership was larger and very active. They did not consider
the First church orthodox and criticised it openly as "having no
principles." Was there room in Wheaton for two Congregational
churches? There was never any thought of the First church uniting
with the College church.
There was no Presbyterian church west
of Maywood. Presbyterian
families coming to Wheaton to make their
home must choose among
the other churches. Why not offer them
a home in their own
denomination? Why not become a Presbyterian
church? There was no
obstacle of faith. The change in church
polity was not too great.
The more the proposition was discussed
the more favorable it
seemed. Overtures were made to the Chicago
Presbytery. The
Presbytery looked upon the matter favorably
and the change was
finally consumated April 20th. 1909, taking over the membership,
the property and the debts of the First
Congregational Church of
Wheaton.
The Presbytery enrolled the church as its one hundreth member
and contributed two hundred dollars toward the salary of a
minister for one year. The Presbyterians had grown from four
churches to one hundred churches and had become one of the
strongest denominations in the Chicago area in sixty years. At the
suggestion of the Presbytery Dr. Shepherd was called to serve the
church and he took up his duties in August. Ninety-two members
were transferred from the old church but the roll of charter
members was to remain open until the first communion October third
when it was completed with one hundred and twenty-six names.
Some changes had taken place in the physical property during
these thirty years. There is a vote of thanks recorded at the
meeting of the church November fifteenth 1894 to Mr. John Quincy
Adams for the gift of the manse. This was a two story frame house
situated on a thirty-five foot lot facing Seminary street and
directly back of the church property and it has served as the
residence of the minister of the church almost continuously since.
A month later Mr. Adams offered a gift of six hundred dollars to
the church toward the purchase of a pipe organ. A very lovely and
acceptable gift. He joined in a committee with Mr. E. W. Fisher
and Mr. H. R. Lewis to raise the balance that would be needed. It
was necessary to build an addition to the east of the church to
house the organ and make a choir loft. The organ was purchased and
installed by Lyon and Healy but five years later the church spent
five hundred dollars "to make a complete pipe organ."
The building lacked a place for social gatherings, for church
dinners, for the primary department and the women's society. A
committee consisting of the Trustees, Miss Adams and Mrs. Patrick
was appointed to explore the possibilities of building an addition
which would meet these needs and to report back to the church at
the earliest possible date. The committee was appointed June 25,
1902 and a week later reported favorably on the project. A
building committee was appointed consisting of Messers Monroe,
Vogell, Jones, Fisher, Miss Adams, Mrs. Patrick and Mrs. Nystrom.
August twenty-third the church authorized the Trustees to mortgage
the church property to the amount of one thousand dollars to the
Congregational Church Building Society for the funds necessary for
the new construction. The mortgage was to be repaid in five annual
installments of two hundred dollars each. The work was completed
and turned over to the Trustees May 6, 1903. This is what
constitutes the "East Room" of the present plant. The small room
to the south was intended for a kitchen and served as such until
the basement was excavated and a new kitchen was equipped in the
room below. During the six remaining years of the Congregational
society no payments were made.
When the Presbyterian society took over the property they paid
off this mortgage but no release was obtained until a final
settlement of an old claim of six hundred and sixty-two dollars by
the Congregational Church Building Society for a mortgage dated
December 2, 1879 was satisfied The latter claim was settled in May
1913 for an amount in excess of six hundred dollars by Mrs.
Katherine Adams Wells. The matter was adjusted and settlement
arrived at by Judge M. Slusser, and a release obtained for each
mortgage on May 19, 1913. These releases were recorded.
In order to pay the one thousand dollar mortgage and other
debts of the Congregational society the Presbyterian society
borrowed twelve hundred and fifty dollars from the First National
Bank of Wheaton and it was sixteen years before this note was
finally redeemed. Had the Congregational Church Building Society
presented claims for both mortgages when the Presbyterian society
took over the property it is likely both would have been paid at
that time but the claim for the first mortgage seems not to have
been pressed until 1913 and the action of Mrs. Wells and Judge
Slusser cleaned up an old and difficult problem for the Trustees
for which both they and the church were very grateful.
During a midsummer storm in 1913 lightning struck the belfry on
the church and damaged it severely. The Trustees could not see any
useful purpose it served and ordered it removed, together with the
pinnacles, to save the expense of rebuilding it. Their removal has
detracted much from the architectural beauty of the building and
lost its churchlike appearance.
The first Session of the Presbyterian church was composed of
Elders George H. Brewster, Frank DeWolf, William H. Monroe, J. 0.
Morris, C. R. Thomas and J. M. Grove.
The first Board of Trustees consisted of C. T. Jones, William
H. Porter, Edward N. Lake and B. L. Ames to which was added the
following year Fred M. Cutter and G. C. Alchorn.
When Dr. Shepherd assumed his duties in August 1909 the
membership of the new church consisted of 92 names from the old
church roll and at his first communion additional members joined
as charter members to bring the number up to one hundred and
twenty-six. During the years of his ministry there were two
hundred and twenty-five additions to the roll and the losses were
forty-two letters granted, fourteen lost by death and fourteen
names placed on the absent roll. This left a net membership of two
hundred and eighty-one at the close of his ministry in June of
1917.
Dr. Shepherd began his work with a broad sympathy and a keen
understanding of the problems facing both the church and the
community. His interest in the young people was particularly
strong and it grieved him that the facilities for recreation were
so inadequate in our city. He soon interested the young men of his
congregation in a project to excavate the basement under the
church and equip it with a maple floor and gymnasium apparatus. He
added to this a pool table. This brought forth severe condemnation
from the College and the College Church. who had never forgotten
their old quarrel. But the church basement was open every night
and it soon became the social and recreational center of the
community as well as for the church young people. It was under
wholesome Christian influences and helped direct many a life into
paths of righteousness.
In theology Dr. Shepherd was considered broad but his teachings
were always simple. He was at heart a teacher and friend. He was
deeply loved by his own people and highly esteemed by most of his
neighbors and fellow townsmen. His influence lasted long after he
had left Wheaton.
In vain the committee sought another Dr. Shepherd. Almost a year
went by with various ministers filling the pulpit. The most
popular of these was a professor of Church History in the Baptist
Theological Seminary, a part of the University of Chicago, Dr.
Peter G. Mode. He was free from his teaching duties during the
summer quarter so the Session decided to ask him to become the
Stated Supply of the church and offered him the use of the manse
and the same salary paid to Dr. Shepherd. This would make a very
welcome addition to his income and provide the family a nice home
with good environments. He accepted the offer and began his
ministry July 24, 1918.
He devoted his full time and energies to the church until
October when he arranged to stay at the University from Monday
through Friday. Dr. Mode was an interesting speaker and drew a
good congregation, especially of men. In spite of his absence from
the field during the midweek he brought many new members into the
church.
It is quite surprising that the Presbytery permitted a Baptist
minister to become a Stated Supply and made no protest throughout
his ministry in the Wheaton Church. It is the present policy of
Presbytery to discourage the use of Stated Supplies for any
lengthy period but rather to encourage the churches in its
jurisdiction to have regularly installed ministers.
Dr. Mode took a protracted vacation during the summer of 1924,
spending his time in Canada where he claimed he had suffered
illness but the Session believed he was preaching each Sunday in
Canadian churches. He claimed full payment for the time he was
away. Twice during October he was away from Wheaton on Sunday
without notifying the Session that he would be away nor making
arrangements for someone to preach in his place. When the Session
remonstrated with him he told them he was in no way subject to
them. His resignation was asked and as he was not an installed
minister of the church no request of Presbytery to dissolve the
pastoral relationship was necessary. He preached his last sermon
to the church November 9, 1924.
The fact that Dr. Mode had enjoyed two sources of income made it
possible for the church to be served by a man whose talents
commanded a salary beyond their means. The church must be content
to engage a man of lesser ability or take the chance of a student
whose ability was yet to be proven. The latter course was chosen
and Winfield Scot Insley, a student at McCormick Theological
Seminary was called. He had been a minister of the Wesleyan
Methodist church in South Dakota before coming to Chicago for
further theological study and was one of the older men in his
class. He was married and had two young sons.
Dr. Insley's ministry covered a span of five years when
financial prosperity was general and optimism for the future
unlimited, April 17, 1925 to December 29, 1929.
What the new minister lacked in the pulpit he more than made up
in youthful enthusiasm and hard work. He was a great favorite
among the young people. He was in demand as a speaker at high
school assemblies. The Christian Endeavor society had become
moribund. It was reorganized into three groups, one for the high
school age, one for teacher's training for the Church School and a
third that would take in all the remainder was given a series of
lectures on the history of the Protestant Church in America. The
new plan must be credited to Elder John L. Alexander whose work
with the American Youth Foundation gave him a broad understanding
of the psychology of youth. The young group took hold with
enthusiasm. They brought their friends and every meeting was a
success. The other churches in Wheaton took note of the
Presbyterian plan and organized like groups.
The Church School was also growing and soon reached a point
when it was a problem to find suitable space for the classes. This
was particularly true of the primary department which used the
East room. This condition was brought up at the annual meeting of
the church in 1929. The discussion resulted in the appointment of
a committee to explore the needs and recommend a new site for the
church plant if they thought it advisable.
The committee reported on four possible sites, as follows;
First, the northeast corner of Union and Wheaton Ave. This
overlooked the park. It was an irregular tract 236 feet by 76 feet
by 114 feet which could be purchased for $32,000. Second, the
southwest corner of Union and West Sts. 141' x 198' to cost about
$25,000. The third; Mrs. Well's "cow pasture" on Cross St back of
the Christian Science church. Mrs. Wells did not favor moving the
church and declined to set a price on this property. And last the
present site which had a frontage of 77' on Hale St and 135' on
Seminary to which must be added the lot on Seminary occupied by
the manse. The committee favored the present site because of its
central location but thought it necessary to secure additional
frontage on Hale St. if only the 5 1/2 feet the church had sold to
William Grote in 1881. This property was now owned by Mr. Fred
Grote, the son of the late William Grote. When approached on the
subject of selling to the church he told the committee he would
not consider selling back the five and a half feet nor did he wish
to dispose of his home. He did agree to inform the church if he
should change his mind and before he sold to anyone.
The church accepted the recommendations of the committee to
remain at the present site and authorized the Trustees to go ahead
with plans for a new structure for both the church and educational
buildings. The Trustees were authorized to borrow up to $75,000
for the completion of at least one unit of the new church plant.
The Trustees entered into arrangements with some professional
campaign promoters to canvass the membership for funds. The
campaign resulted in pledges for $45,000. payable over a period of
three years. A finance committee was appointed to collect and
handle these funds. Another committee was appointed to make a
study of the needs of the church and to select an architect. This
committee visited a number of new church structures and
interviewed many of the leading church architects. The first
question raised by these architects was "can you secure more
land?" The size of the lot appeared altogether too small for the
ambitions of the church and its future growth.
The chairman of this building committee was Mr. Hugo Schmidt
who was an architect and engineer. At his own expense he prepared
a set of plans for a church, manse and educational building, all
under one roof, that he believed could be built on the available
ground. A cut of this proposed building was published in one of
the local papers. The educational unit was to be erected first and
the estimated cost of this unit was well over $75,000. When it
seemed probable that the church would go ahead without Mr. Grote's
property, he became very much interested and sent word to the
committee that he would like to see them. He told them that he had
a offer from some promoters who wanted to build an apartment house
on his property but that he had given his word to consult the
church before making a sale to anyone. His asking price was
$25,000.
This price seemed very high but after finding the price asked
for vacant property across the street and taking into
consideration the prices asked the committee that had canvassed
other available sites, the Trustees concluded to recommend the
purchase to the congregation. A few years later, after the bubble
had burst, it seemed incredible that such a price should have been
considered. The purchase was made with a payment of about
$10,000., all that was in the building fund treasury. The balance
of $15,000. was carried through the depression years with only
small payments being made on the principal, mostly coming from the
Women's Society. Some of the Trustees would like to have given the
property back to Mr. Grote if he would cancel the note but the
majority disagreed with them. Finally bonds were issued to members
of the church bearing three percent interest, to be paid off by
lot on any interest date and an amount added to the annual budget
to cover the interest and amortization of the debt. Mr. Grote
agreed to a reduction of one thousand dollars of the balance in
consideration of a cash settlement.
The Grote residence was turned into quarters for the primary
department which relieved the pressure to do something for the
Church School. In view of the financial difficulties of the
depression years it is doubtful if the church could have weathered
the storm had it had a debt of fifty or seventy-five thousand
dollars to carry. Mr. Grote did the church a great service of
which he was not aware.
During the Holiday week of 1928 the Gary Memorial Church was
completely destroyed by fire. They had to rebuild and it was
suggested that as the property adjoined and both churches were
about to build, they combine and build one fine church which would
serve the united congregations. Committees from the two churches
met and discussed the problems entailed in such a merger. They
finally agreed on a joint meeting in Chicago where Dr. Henry
Seymour Brown, Executive Secretary of the Chicago Presbytery and
Bishop Hughes of the Methodist Church would be present. Bishop
Hughes generously offered to take the entire membership of the
Presbyterian church into the membership of the Gary Memorial
Church but further than that he would make no concessions. There
was no further talk of a merger.
The year 1929 closed with the resignation of the Reverend Mr.
Insley who had received a call to the First Presbyterian Church of
Shenandoah, Iowa. He had served the church well and had added one
hundred and ninety-two members to the rolls. Of course this was
not a net gain of that many for there had been the usual losses by
death and dismissal by letter as well as some who had moved away
and had not transferred their membership. The church was in good
condition and looked forward confidently to the future.
By Easter of 1930 the committee that had been appointed to
nominate a new minister was ready to present Dr. Bishop Newsom.
His work as an educator in Texas, Oklahoma and Kansas and a degree
of Doctor of Religious Education conferred by Northwestern
University seemed to point to him as a man of large experience and
perhaps another Dr. Mode. The committee tried to make clear to him
the program for social and religious life for the young people of
the church and desire to continue such a program. He expressed
himself as fully in accord with it. He was told particularly of
Dr. Shepherd and his work in Wheaton to which he nodded assent.
Within six months he had antagonized many of the young people and
they had dropped their activities.
Dr. Newsom was a great success as a teacher or a lecturer on
Old Testament history but in the pulpit there were few who liked
him. His theories for organization of Christian Education were
very complex and entirely over the heads of his church school
officers and teachers. The years of the depression were upon us
and finances became a great problem. Money was scarce and called
for a great sacrifice on the part of those who endeavored to keep
up their former pledges to the budget. The congregation dwindled
to a mere handful and it seemed that something must be done if the
church was to survive. The turn in the road was made in the summer
of 1935 when Dr. Newsom decided to resign. His work started June
30,1930 and ended June 30,1935. He had received one hundred
members into the church.
It took the committee almost a year to locate a new minister
that they would recommend. The Trustees told the committee that
they could pay $1500. a year and that $1800. was positively the
top limit. The men interviewed were not interested in such a
salary or if they were interested the committee was not interested
in them. They had scouted many churches and had arranged to have
candidates preach in city churches where they could go and hear
them. They finally made a wise choice in the Reverend Pyron
McMillen who was student supply minister in the Central Church of
Chicago.
Mr. McMillen had another year to complete his seminary course.
He began preaching as a supply June 4th, 1936 and was installed as
minister of the church upon his completion of his work in the
seminary April 25, 1937. Mr. McMillen brought with him a youthful
enthusiasm and tireless energy that more than compensated for his
lack of experience. He was very devout and sought to instill a
spirit of evangelism in every department of the church. He rallied
the lagging forces of the church and put new life and hope into
it. That his labor here was short lived casts no reflection upon
his ministry, nor does it mark a dissatisfaction on either side.
He felt that because he had served the church during his student
days he would always be looked upon as a novice and that only in
some other field would he be accepted as a skilled workman. A call
to a well established church in a college town appealed to him
greatly but he was loth to give up a work that he felt and knew
was just well started. Torn between his desire to enter what
seemed to him a larger field and his sense of loyalty to the many
friends in Wheaton, it was with great reluctance that he tendered
his resignation at the annual meeting in 1938. He had done much
for the church during the two short years of his pastorate. He
came to a discouraged congregation and left a united, hopeful
people. The pastorate was dissolved April 15, 1938.
No history of this church would be complete without reference
to an activity which, starting with small beginnings, has
continued uninterrupted for over thirty years. It can best be told
in the words of the late John L. Alexander, "Kinji" to his
friends, as he wrote in the Founders' Magazine in 1926.
"Spreading, the Christmas Cheer." "A little church in the suburbs
of Chicago has annually for nearly a score of years, carried on
the Christmas spirit. So well has it been done that the suburban
town, in which the little church is located, has united its
efforts with the church in a great nonsectarian Christmas
enthusiasm. The result has been a months' or six weeks' planning
for the event on the day before Christmas and giving the day
before Christmas to personally visit the needy homes and deliver
the food baskets, clothing and toys. "I was sick and ye visited me
- hungry and ye fed me - Naked and ye clothed me - lonely and ye
came in unto me." In passing it may be noted that the movement is
the direct result of a big-hearted business man, who began it by
caring for a couple of families at Christmas time. "The cup of
water given for Thee, still holds the freshness of Thy Grace."
Many have answered the last roll call since the church became
Presbyterian. Of these a word of appreciation should be said for
their faithful courage through days or darkness and trial.
Outstanding among them we find George H. Brewster, William Monroe,
DeWitt C. Blair, John L. Alexander, Edward N. Lake, Charles J.
Jones, Miss Alice Fisher, Mrs. Edith Pittsford and Mrs. Henrietta
Wanzer. Indeed they have "fought the good fight, they have kept
the faith" and we who are left to carry on may well be inspired by
their faith and courage.
The Presbyterian Church was now approaching its thirtieth
birthday, and had run a life span equal to the Congregational
Church after the secession of the College Church. Had the
proponents of the change to the Presbyterian standard been right?
Had the church made better progress than the old church? From a
membership of 65 in 1879 to that of 92 in 1909 was a gain of fifty
per cent. From 92 to 271 in 1938 was a gain of 300%. From fifteen
ministers with an average of two years to five ministers with an
average of six years. Current expenses were being met and the only
debt was the unpaid balance on the purchase of the Grote property.
The congregation, while not large or wealthy, was made up of
substantial, friendly people who made a compact working
organization. Having given up the autonomy of the Congregational
Church they had gained the democracy of representative government.
Presbytery never exercised any dictatorial rule over the church.
In fact it could not do so but it stood ready to assist in any
time of need. While the ordained Elders and Deacons are required
to accent the Confession of Faith there are no "testimonies" that
a member must subscribe to when joins the church save his belief
in God, the Father, and in Jesus Christ, the Savior and Redeemer
of men. They are asked to give a little of their time, of their
energy, of their prayers and of their means to the welfare of the
church.
The committee delegated to find a successor to Mr. McMillen
made use of their friends and found a young man from New York
through Dr. Brackett, minister of the church at Lake Forest. He
was Robert Bowman Stewart, associate minister in the Collegiate
Church of St. Nicholas, a Dutch Reformed church having a
Presbyterian form of government. Mr. Stewart was a graduate of
Columbia University and Princeton Theological Seminary, and seemed
to offer all the qualifications they desired. In order to persuade
him to look over Wheaton, two of the committee brought him to
Wheaton one warm August afternoon and showed him the church
property and the beautiful little city. They took him to call on a
few of the citizens so he might know the kind of people he would
find here.
It was asking a good deal of this young man to give up a good
salary for a meager one, a big Metropolitan Church for a little
country church but Dr. Stewart agreed to think it over and decide
by Labor Day. His letter came promptly and said he "thought his
chapter in New York was not yet finished." The committee had
feared this might be the answer but they were determined at one
more attempt. A night letter was telegraphed immediately which
reached him Sunday morning as he was preparing for the pulpit. He
tried to formulate a reply but gave it up and resorted to the long
distance telephone. He made the call but before he was able to
give his negative answer he found himself reconsidering and
promising to preach as a candidate the first Sunday evening in
October. There was no doubt in the minds of the committee that the
matter was settled. He received a unanimous call and arrived in
Wheaton November 15, 1938.
The installation service of the Reverend Robert Bowman Stewart
as minister of the First Presbyterian Church of Wheaton was held
December 15th. at which the Reverend Frederick F. Shannon D.D.
minister of the Central Church of Chicago, preached the sermon.
The Reverend Robert H. Elliott Ph.D. gave the charge to the
minister, and the Reverend W. Oliver Brackett, Ph.D. minister of
the Lake Forest Presbyterian Church, gave the charge to the
Congregation.
The church people turned out well to hear Dr. Stewart's first
sermon. They went home to tell their friends and neighbors. The
next Sunday the doors to the South room had to be raised to
accommodate the crowd. By Christmas many were unable to get in.
There were visitors coming from near and far to hear him and many
predictions were made that the Wheaton church would not be able to
keep him long in such a small church. Mr. Stewart found he liked
the people as well as they liked him and a bond of friendship soon
existed that would be hard to break. When asked why he came to
Wheaton he said that any church that had members willing to give
up their business in behalf of the church as two of them had done
when they took him out to see Wheaton and the church must have the
right kind of people in its congregation.
Work on the manse was started as soon as Dr. Stewart arrived.
It was no small undertaking as it required a new roof, new
gutters, a new chimney, a new bath room, and a new furnace.
Painting and decorating both floors, a new partition between the
hall and the living room and shoring up the floors in the kitchen
and dining room and the removal of an old kitchen chimney which
had caused the floors to settle, all were attended to and a
livable house was the result. Perhaps the greatest result was the
enthusiasm and activity which this work engendered.
The next project undertaken was landscaping the grounds. A work
party of the men was organized and in a couple of evenings the
rubbish was cleared away, the space between the church and the
manse was graded and planted with shrubs and evergreens. Dr.
Stewart designed and built a friendship garden behind the house
and a terrace where he might entertain his guests during warn
weather. Yes, the old church had taken on a new life and a new era
was begun.
One summer morning in 1941 the old organ refused to function.
For over forty five years it had presided over the auditorium,
with its ornamental pipes of various sizes, highly decorated save
where the paint had chipped. There had been little change in the
sanctuary since it was installed excepting that the old stove no
longer dispensed comfort or discomfort to the congregation and
electricity had displaced the oil lamps. The pulpit rostrum was
somewhat lower than the choir or organ loft. The organist sat with
her back to the audience but watched what was going on thru a rear
view mirror. The choir sat on either side of the organ bench with
a rail separating them from the speaker.
All this would be changed when the new organ was installed. An
addition had to be built to house the organ mechanics and the
manuel was set on the floor level at the right of the rostrum. The
cost of the new organ was less than the estimated cost of repairs
on the old one. The manufacturer allowed one hundred dollars for
the old one and it now serves in a Jewish Synagogue. The removal
left a black cave with an accumulation of dirt in which was found
a copy of the manuel of the First Congregational Church bearing
the date 1884.
A special service to dedicate the chancel and the new organ was
held Sunday afternoon November 14, 1943, that being the fifth
anniversary of Dr. Stewart's arrival in Wheaton.
A very excellent and interesting description of the composition
of the chancel was written by Mrs. Shelby McMillion for the Wheaton Journal July 16, 1951.
Mrs. Catherine Adams Wells, who with her father, John Quincy
Adams, had been benefactors of the church since 1884, passed away
November 14, 1942. In her will she left a trust of twenty-five
thousand dollars for the benefit of the church. During her life
she had done many nice things for the church among them paying off
the claims of the Congregational Church Building Society,
carpeting the main auditorium, painting the church at her expense
several times, (the color had to be stone gray), and she had
contributed generously "for the support of the minister."
Dr. Stewart conceived the idea of an outdoor chapel. It was a
rectangular area surrounded by dense hedges. A stone altar was
erected at the south end and an entrance through an iron gate was
at the north end. Crushed lime stone was spread in the shape of a
cross with a stone seat on either side of the path. This beautiful
little chapel was dedicated to the memory of Gilbert Monroe Cole,
an aviator who lost his life in the Second World War. Gilbert was
the grandson of William Monroe, a charter member and one of the
first Elders of the Presbyterian Church. The chapel found much use
during the summer months for baptisms and weddings.
Early in Dr. Stewart's ministry a new choir was organized under
the direction of Mr. Morris F. Roberts, with Mrs. Joseph A.
Reinhardt at the organ. Both were musicians of unusual ability.
Mr. Roberts secured a quartet of singers through the Chicago
Musical College and made up the chorus from the best young voices
in the congregation. The choir has been a great asset to the
church at Christmas and Easter when they put on special programs
as well as every Sunday morning from September to June.
The right arm of the church is the Women's Society. The ladies
work from January first through December thirty-first on various
projects that contribute to the life and activity of the church.
They contribute generously to the church, the Church School, the
building fund and to various benevolences. "The Spiritual Life
Group has been a vital center open to each of us helping us along
the road to better understanding." The calls upon new families in
Wheaton does much to give a cordial welcome to them to come to our
church. You can always depend on the chancel guild for a beautiful
and artistic arrangement of the flowers that grace the chancel and
the vestibule entrance to the church.
The church membership had grown in ten years to 475 and the
"little country church" was beginning to take on metropolitan
ways. The annual meeting in January 1950 marked a new advance
which was ultimately to make great changes.
THE CHURCH MOVES.
The period of the thirties, with its general
depression, had brought new home building to a
minimum and without new homes the population of
Wheaton grew very slowly. Late in the decade a
few residences were started only to be finished
under great difficulty and further building was
prohibited because of the Second World War. The
birth rate had been exceedingly low so that the
school population was about static and no new
school buildings were required.
This trend was reversed in the forties. Marriages increased as
the boys were called up to go to war and when they returned after
the middle of the decade. The effect on the school population was
felt generally throughout the country but especially in Wheaton
where new home construction was particularly active and where the
influx of new families had swelled the population from about seven
thousand in 1940 to about twelve thousand in 1950. Most of this
growth came in the last four years and the trend was continuing.
Again the Church School needed space, particularly for the
primary department. Dr. Stewart called the attention of the
congregation to this need at the annual meeting of January 1950. A
committee was appointed to survey the needs and explore ways and
means of meeting them. This committee made a very thorough study
of the situation and invited a New York architect, who was the
advisory architect of the Church Federation, to an all day meeting
of the committee to consult with them on their findings. A lengthy
report had been prepared and was read to the architect. He
congratulated them on the comprehensive treatment they had given
the subject but, he inquired, "where will you locate such a
building?" The area south of the church seemed ample to them but
the architect pointed out that while that was true it would leave
little or no room for the future growth of the church, especially
in view of the need of a new sanctuary before many years.
The children's building, as outlined, would probably cost one
hundred and fifty thousand dollars. One of the members of the
committee suggested that in view of the fact that we had little
space for future expansion if we built on the present site, why
not look at the Dunbar property which was for sale at about half
the amount we proposed to spend for the building and would give
ample room for future growth. It would solve the problem of
traffic congestion that was growing serious at the time the Sunday
school was dismissed and people were coming to the three or four
churches in the immediate vicinity. During the luncheon recess
many of the committee drove around the Dunbar property and were
favorably impressed.
David Dunbar was a successful Chicago lawyer who had lived in
Wheaton many years. He secured title to all the lots in a block
bounded by Madison, Ellis, Jefferson and Carlton avenues,
approximately four hundred feet square, and erected a beautiful
residence of Georgian architecture in 1930 at an estimated cost of
one hundred and fifty thousand dollars. The grounds were
beautifully landscaped and occupied a hilltop in the northwest
section of Wheaton, about a mile from the old church property.
After the death of Mr. Dunbar only Mrs. Dunbar remained to
occupy this immense house. She had tried unsuccessfully to sell
the property for some time and offered it to the committee for
seventy five thousand dollars cash. The committee considered it
very carefully and found the floor area about the same as they had
planned for the children's building. With only a few minor changes
it would serve the school very well and as a home for the Women's
society and the Youth groups it seemed ideal. The congregation
approved the purchase and a sixty day option was secured. During
the next two months an exhaustive campaign for funds resulted in
cash and pledges for over seventy thousand dollars. The banks made
a loan of forty thousand dollars for a period of five years.
Within eighteen months more than half of this loan was repaid.
Late in September of 1950 the Church school moved into the new
home which was to be called the Parish House. It required some new
equipment and considerable adjusting to get the departments
arranged to the best advantage. The school began to take on new
life and the growth exceeded all expectations. The Children's
Building Committee cannot be too highly praised for their
excellent work in bringing to pass such a large project in so
short a time.
The Women's Association took up quarters in the Parish House
and found it a most ideal place for their all-day meetings,
dinners and receptions. Their membership was growing rapidly and
their enthusiasm high. They pledged five thousand dollars toward
the purchase of the Parish House and redeemed their pledge in full
within a year. They also gave liberally toward furnishings and
improvements.
The Young people were delighted to have the ball room converted
into a chapel for their use and a rumpus room in the basement
where they could hold their social affairs with a kitchen, well
equipped, for their use. The Presbyteens, a high school group, the
Presbyterian Junior League, a group of junior high school students
and the Supper Club, a group of young married couples are all
proud of their new quarters. In the hands of these young people
lies the future church.
The distance between the church and the Parish House causes
some inconvenience, but it is not of a serious nature. It is well
understood that this is temporary. The advantages of the new
location are many and the goal set before the congregation is the
early completion of the entire church plant. With this in view the
building committee called a meeting of the Church and Congregation
May 18th, 1952 at the Wheaton Community High School at which
meeting sketches were presented showing the design and location of
the Sanctuary, the Educational Building, and the Manse. The
Congregation gave its approval of the plans which were all in
Georgian architecture to be in keeping with the Parish House. It
also asked the Trustees to endeavor to find a buyer for the
present church property. The Building Committee was instructed to
proceed with raising the money that would be required to complete
the entire project or at least enough to build the Sanctuary.
For a time one delay followed another until early in 1954 a new
chairman was appointed and several new names added to the
committee. Then business began to move. A Company was engaged to
head up the canvass for funds and after carefully laying the
ground work the campaign got into action May first 1953 and closed
six weeks later with $160,000. raised in cash and pledges.
Meanwhile the architects, Tranchetti and Sutor, completed the
working plans and specifications for the Sanctuary and called for
bids which resulted in the contract being awarded to the LaSalle
Construction Co. of Chicago.
A special congregational meeting was held in the sanctuary,
Sunday November 15 1953 at five in the afternoon to consider the
report of the Building Committee and related matters, including
the proposed sale of all the church property fronting on Hale and
Seminary streets. The meeting authorized the sale at a price of
$66,000, the church to have continued use of the building until
August first 1954.
A week later the congregation was invited to the site of the
new church for the informal ceremony of breaking ground for the
new Sanctuary. "This is a joyous and historic event."
Another joyous event occurred May 9, 1954 when the corner stone
was laid with impressive ceremonies. The box containing historic
data, the membership roll of the Church - the last Easter Sermon
preached in the old Church by Dr. Stewart and the Church Calender
for May 9th, was set in place by Elder Chauncey Mc Cormick and the
stone was placed by Walter Bryant, Chairman of the Building
Committee.
The church membership has not been standing still. When Dr.
Stewart was installed there were 291 names on the active roll. The
clerk's report at the close of 1953 showed an active membership of
692, and over 80% of these had known no other minister here. Few
of the original members of the Presbyterian church are now living
and those who cast their lot with them in the early days are few
in numbers but the church owes much to the memory of those who,
through all the years, carried on the work of Christ and the
Church in spite of discouragement and adversity. They were a fine
group of men and women who worked together as a unit for the
advancement of Christ's Kingdom.
We owe a debt of gratitude to those men and women, few in
numbers but strong in faith and courage, who built our sanctuary
almost three quarters of a century ago. We have been their heirs
and beneficiaries through many years altho their names are well
nigh forgotten.
"May we bear in mind that all we have today is the fruit of the
labors of these pioneers, who wrought in years gone by under the
blessing of the Great Head of the Church, our Divine Lord and
Savior. Let us pray earnestly that we may be given the grace to
continne these labors in the same spirit of consecration and build
upon the same foundation of which they built; 'For other
foundation can no man lay than that is laid, which is Jesus
Christ.'"*
*The words of the Reverend Cleveland Frame at the one hundred
and fiftieth General Assembly of the Presbyterian Church U.S.A. |